Very few lines of snooker commentary are remembered. Indeed, many would argue that most are better forgotten.
Ted Lowe’s hushed, concerned ‘no’ when Steve Davis missed the black against Dennis Taylor stands out, but the best known sentence uttered in a snooker commentary box came courtesy of Jack Karnehm.
The son of a Czechoslavkian baron, Karnehm’s own World Championship record was not to be envied. In three appearances in the qualifiers he failed to win a single frame in the 28 he played.
Billiards was his sport. He won the UK Championship at the three ball game in 1980 and lost in two world finals.
Indeed, he appeared in one of Roger Lee’s heritage room DVDs with John Pulman, in which he stated he always made a 500 break at billiards before breakfast.
“Yes, Jack,” said the laconic Pulman, “but you don’t eat until two in the afternoon.”
Karnehm had a great voice for commentary. Never demonstrative or intrusive, he kept his comments to a minimum, as was the style in the 1980s.
In 1983 he found himself commentating on the opening session of Cliff Thorburn’s second round match against Terry Griffiths at the Crucible.
At the start of the fourth frame, Thorburn fluked a red and so began the dramatic build up to his 147.
As Cliff stood over the final black, poised to make history a ball away from making the World Championship’s first maximum break, Karnehem looked down from the box and said simply: “Good luck, mate.”
There was no hype, no talking over the moment. He just put into words what everyone was thinking.
The addition of “mate” was the masterstroke. It gave the impression, rightly or not, that this happy band of snooker folk were pals, grateful that they had been given a moment in the spotlight after years of toil before the BBC showed interest in covering the game and thus happy that one of their own was about to experience such elation.
The previous year, Karnehm had also commentated on the classic semi-final between Alex Higgins and Jimmy White, one of many golden moments to which he lent his distinctive voice.
Karnehm’s other crucial contribution to the World Championship was in manufacturing the famous ‘upside down’ spectacles sported by Dennis Taylor.
Taylor was much mocked for his appearance but, of course, had the last laugh. Indeed, still is.
Karnehm’s commentary, like that of Lowe, was of its time. Television has changed. Doubtless many would say not for the better.
Karnehm commentated for the BBC from 1978 until 1993. He died in 2002 at the age of 85.
20 comments:
Karnehm, Lowe, Everton...the commentators in the old days only spoke when they knew they were actually enhancing the story of the match. These days a lot of them just gabble on and have a loose grasp of grammar.
1024, many slag the bbc, but eurosport have many worse offenders...
mr my apologies, the guy who thinks every double is a cross double, is the worst of the bunch.
daves good.
the mike guy and joe are comedy genuis, but unfortunately they dont mean it and im not wanting to laugh at them while watching snooker.
sure dave, or someone else, will defend them, but if anyone on here actually watches back to hear how often they speak and how often what they say is true or turns out a complete stab in the dark guess...its embarrasing.
(ps, im dyslexic so would rather not be given a lesson by the resident english teach on here)
jack was fantastic btw!!
Karnehm's "Good luck mate" to Cliff Thorburn, when he was on the brink of the 147, will always stay in my mind.
Jack told me that Cliff was his favourite player and he had a framed photograph of him on the wall of his snooker room at home. He couldn't stand Alex Higgins though (I had to bite my tongue at this because I'm an Alex fan)
Strange to think that he said that although he commentated and coached it, snooker wasn't his game as he was a billiards man.
many guys of the late 70s were billiards men, 1220.
wasnt strange to hear that back then
I think television has changed for the better, the choice we have now is exceptional.
Yes, it does mean a lot of fodder is put on, but equally it also means there is a lot more quality to choose from.
Like most things, technology has helped to shape the evolution. Innovations such as i-players, red buttons and player cams have given people different ways to enjoy their viewing experience.
I've never brought all the talk of a TV golden age in the past. It is a myth.
On the subject of commentary, I think these type of mikesmiths have a place, but I'm not irritated by the modern commentator who likes to talk more.
John McEnroe and Geoffrey Boycott talk a lot and would be in my top five commentators of all time.
Here is my top ten:
1. Stuart Storey
2. Clive Everton
3. Geoffrey Boycott
4. John McEnroe
5. Richie Benaud
6. Bill McLaren
7. Martin Tyler
8. Peter Alliss
9. John Lloyd
10. Ray French
Good to see Wattana get a victory yesterday, a tricky opponent in Li Yan had to be negotiated. The Thai has a decent chance of making it to Sheffield, a possible final round clash with Ryan Day is by no means a difficult one. Day looks woefully out of sorts this season.
Luca Brecel seems to have the bit between his teeth, very impressed by his demolition of Ian McCulloch.
Drago is on the comeback trail, Justin Astley will feel like he has been hit by a Tornado!
that was years before i was even born, but indeed a very nice read.
thanks, mate! ;)
More coverage isn't the same as more choice Jamie. Generally I'd agree with you that in terms of snooker viewing it's better than it used to be, but outside of snooker I don't find myself spoilt for choice. More channels doesn't necessarily mean more top writers and producers making more high quality programmes.
I think Jamie makes a fair point. If you listen to some of Lowe's commentaries on Youtube, it's difficult to see how he's "adding to the picture" as many like to say. Often he would come out with banalities such as "and he's got this red into the centre pocket" in his overly dramatic voice when it was bloody obvious what shot he was about to play. That said, I enjoyed his commentary at the time but it's been overtaken by the passage of time. Nowadays, not just in snooker, the emphasis is on technical knowledge and that's where some of the oldies fell short.
Jack was an excellent commentator. Another memorable line of his was "This man's the Rolls Royce of snooker".. and he was referring to Jimmy White of course.
I'm surprised to hear tht Jack didn't win a single frame in the WC qualifiers. I know that he was a well-respected snooker coach and had coached a young Steve Davis.
Gone...but not forgotten...nice article Dave.
Hi David. " Good luck mate." - A legendary line, from a legendany man.
There is still a huge amount of quality drama, comedy, factual and entertainment programming being made.
I think more choice has enabled the quality to go up in this case.
I rarely find a week go by when you can't find at least one quality show a night.
Jack & Clive were very knowledgeable, but the same can't be said for Ted Lowe. Did he ever play the game?
i find clive everton to be in the jk mould.
states the obvious.
he potted that red and made sure he was top side of the blue
you dont say clive!!
I've never heard CE say "top side of the blue". For one, it's said by WT, and CE and WT can't stand each other.
I actually forgot the brilliant David Lloyd from Sky's superb cricket coverage.
The cricket is the sports coverage I enjoy most on Sky.
The only pity has been Test Cricket losing it's appeal with the public, due to the lack of free to air coverage. I'm pretty concerned about where the sport is heading.
Anonymous said...
I've never heard CE say "top side of the blue". For one, it's said by WT, and CE and WT can't stand each other.
12:10 PM
---------------------------
well, because youve never heard him say it we must think he hasnt ever then, eh?
grow up!
its a common snooker phrase and has been since well before WT retired and went in the box.
jamie brannon said...
I actually forgot the brilliant David Lloyd from Sky's superb cricket coverage.
The cricket is the sports coverage I enjoy most on Sky.
The only pity has been Test Cricket losing it's appeal with the public, due to the lack of free to air coverage. I'm pretty concerned about where the sport is heading.
11:54 AM
---------------------
today i am going to talk about bananas.
im going to do it on a snooker blog, cause thats where i happen to be.
Colin 11.46....
Remember it well.
I'm sure it was the Rothman's 1986.
Either during his match with Hendry, the semi with dodgy Francisco or maybe the final v Sexy Rexy.
Karnehm was fantastic. Everything he said was all observed and worth listening to.
Much missed.
Post a Comment